BAI directly links Lee Myung-bak to Four Rivers Project disaster

Spokesperson for South Korea’s Board of Audit and Inspection (BAI) Park Chan-seok announces the results of the BAI’s assessment and analysis of the Four Rivers Project on July 4. (Kim Seong-gwang, staff photographer)

Orders to begin project came after Lee’s announcement that he would halt canal construction

The open secret of the Four Rivers Project has finally been confirmed. The dredging of the Nakdong River to a minimum depth of six meters and the construction of 16 massive weirs holding 800 million tons of waters on the four rivers without any plan for their use was ultimately ordered by former president Lee Myung-bak, according to an audit by South Korea’s Board of Audit and Inspection (BAI).

This is the first time that the BAI has directly mentioned Lee. When the BAI announced the results of its audit into the execution of major contracts, including design and overall bidding on the project to revive the four rivers, in July 2013, it only said that the decision to pursue the Four Rivers Project had been made “with a future canal in mind” and “in line with a request from the presidential office.”

According to the results of an assessment of the execution of the project to revive the four rivers and an analysis of its results that the BAI made public on July 4, the Four Rivers Project began after Lee instructed Jung Jong-hwan, then Minister of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs, to move forward with a waterway renovation project. These instructions were given two months after Lee announced in June 2008 that he would give way to public opinion and halt a massive canal project.

After the Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs briefed Lee on plans to prevent flooding by strengthening levies and dredging rivers, Lee instructed the Ministry to augment the plan with the construction of weirs and a plan created by the Korean Peninsula Great Canal Task Force during the presidential transitional committee, the BAI said.

When the Ministry reported in mid-February 2009 that a minimum depth of 2.5-3m was adequate for preventing flooding and dealing with water shortages, Lee personally ordered the depth to be increased to 4-5m, and a “presidential order” was also given in mid-April for the Nakdong River to be dredged to a minimum depth of 6m, the BAI said. In line with these directions, the final plan for the Four Rivers Project was announced in June without any technical analysis by the Ministry.

A photo posted by former President Lee Myung-bak on Oct. 2, 2014 to his Facebook page, showing him cycling along the North Han River. Lee commented on how refreshing his ride was. The river he’s cycling along was affected by his disastrous Four Major Rivers Project, which caused severe damage to ecosystems throughout the country. Civic group Green Korea called the project a big waste of taxpayer money and a hoax meant to fulfill Lee’s dream of building a canal through the Korean peninsula. Jang Seok-hyo, a close associate of Lee’s, was recently arrested on charges of accepting bribes related to the Four Major Rivers Project, which continues to become a more pressing issue. (captured from Lee Myung-bak’s Facebook page)

”Presidential instructions” also behind shortening of environmental impact assessment

The BAI also concluded that “presidential instructions” were behind the Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs’ decision to accelerate by one year its original plan to begin work in Jan. 2010 and finish in 2012 and the Ministry of Environment’s decision to shorten the period of time for the preliminary environmental review and the environmental impact assessment, which normally take between 5-10 months, to 2-3 months.

“Auditors sought to receive a direct explanation from Lee about why he gave such orders. However, they were unable to confirm the reasons or grounds for these orders because Lee did not consent to receiving a visit or a questionnaire,” the BAI said.

BAI says Lee cannot be held legally responsible for project

The BAI’s position is that Lee cannot be held legally responsible because there are no grounds for concluding that Lee’s instructions were illegal.

“The president’s actions on the job cannot be subjected to a job audit, and no illegal activities by the president were discovered. It’s not possible to file charges against him for refusing to cooperate [with the audit],” said Namgung Gi-jeong, director of the BAI’s bureau for land and maritime affairs, during a briefing on July 4.

But regardless of whether Lee is held legally responsible, there are increasing calls for him to be held accountable on a political and moral level.

“The Four Rivers Project was a disaster in which the entire government – including the president; the Blue House; the Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs; the Ministry of Environment; the Korea Water Resources Corporation, and the Ministry of Strategy and Finance – was dragooned into violating our nation’s land. Lee Myung-bak, who was the prime mover of the Four Rivers Project, should be immediately investigated and prosecuted according to the law, while the public servants who abused their authority or abetted his mistakes should be held accountable as well,” said the Citizens’ Committee for Restoring the Four Rivers to their Natural Condition in a statement released on Wednesday.

By Kim Jeong-su, senior staff writer, and Noh Ji-won, staff reporter

Please direct comments or questions to [[e-mail]]